Garron Decision Upheld by Tax Court of Canada

December 2nd, 2010.

The Tax Court of Canada (TCC) decision in Garron, now known as St. Michael Trust Corp., was upheld in a recent Federal Court of Appeal (FCA) decision that serves as a warning that residency issues for trusts — and for corporations — should be taken seriously.

The decision concerned the residency of two trusts, and held that similar considerations should apply as are required to determine the residency of a corporation.

The FCA agreed with the TCC’s determination that the trusts at issue were resident in Canada and not Barbados since, among other reasons, the trusts’ real decision makers were their beneficiaries, who were Canadian residents. Therefore, the capital gains realized by the trusts were taxable and not treaty exempt. There is also a lengthy discussion in obiter of other issues in the event the trusts were resident in Barbados, including the application of section 94 of the Income Tax Act, the application of the Canada-Barbados Tax Treaty to exempt the gains and the application of the General Anti-Avoidance Rule (GAAR).

Had residency in Barbados been successfully established for the trusts, the tax planning would have been successful, i.e., the gains would have been exempt under the treaty and the GAAR would not have applied.

Author: Warren Orlans

Welcome to inTAXicating. inTAXicating has been published since 2008 to provide clarity around Canadian taxation issues, primarily related to the Canada Revenue Agency. As the primary author, Warren Orlans, has over 20-year's experience in the taxation industry, 11 of them working for the Canada Revenue Agency (CRA), and 7-years working in the private sector Managing the tax departments for large financial institutions. If you have a collections, compliance or audit issue with the CRA, inTAXicating is the place you need to contact. inTAXicating works in strategic partnership with amazing accountants, tax lawyers, insolvency practitioners, mortgage brokers, debt counselling experts and much more. If you have a tax question, feel free to ask in the comments, or email me at either, or

Would Love to Hear Your Thoughts

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s